A rant on choosing only one career

by Marian Schembari on November 10, 2009

My awesome roommate and I have lived together since freshman year of college – we talk a lot, and there’s pretty much nothing we don’t know about each other. A few weeks ago we had a heart to heart that I can’t stop thinking about and now I’m mentioning it to everyone. Friends, colleagues, family, random people on the street. So let me set the scene:

Muffin, as she is known around the house, is an actress. A very VERY good one. She is also a mean baker, a health nut, and a gluten-free advocate. She’s also a fantastic writer, a comedienne, the best grocery-shopper I have ever known. As I mentioned in an earlier post, she moved to New York to pursue theater, and while I know she will be hugely successful, she wants to spend her life doing ALL the things she loves, not just one.

We’re allowed to be good at more than one thing

I moved to New York to pursue publishing. But I also love to write, cook, paint things and generally be crafty. But I moved to New York to work with books, meaning the only acceptable path in my life is to start at the bottom and work my way up. Apparently I have to always work with books. In the course of 20 years I should be the best in my field, giving speeches, teaching 20-somethings and successfully wearing pantsuits. Ew.

My mom (also awesome) wanted to join the ministry when she was my age. Then she dropped out of college and became a DJ, then a reporter for CNN. She then became an author and wrote a book about the TWA 800 crash. Because of this she became an expert. So she joined an aviation law firm as an investigator. She now writes freelance and is a Principal at Humanitarian Research Services. During all this time (I’ve left quite a bit out) she traveled to the Sahara to dig up a plane, moved to Syria to learn Arabic… The list goes on. I basically want to be my mom. I have a million passions and ideas and the thought of doing one thing for my entire life makes me tired. I also think it makes me boring. The least boring person on the planet is my mother. Who DOESN’T want to be that awesome?

Why is it that our society expects us to choose one thing and stick with it forever? People who jump from one job to the next are usually seen as irresponsible and flaky. But really they’re interesting and… here’s that word again… awesome.

I’ve started writing freelance, and have been hitting a few roadblocks. I have a few clips, but nothing major. But I’m 22, give me a break! But in journalism, regardless of your ideas or your writing ability, unless you’ve written for a major national magazine or newspaper, no one gives a crap. I pitched a story a few weeks ago to Major Parenting Magazine. The idea rocked. Editor was interested. She responded right away, we emailed back and forth, I wrote a nice long pitch, got my sources, etc etc. I gave her writing samples. Which is when it stalled. Apparently, I couldn’t write for MPM unless I had already written for another magazine, similar to theirs. Um…. Hello?! How does that make any sense? If you like my writing and you like my idea, what’s the damn problem? And do I need to mention the fact that it’s a vicious circle and how does anyone get anywhere with this mentality? I have written before, and the writing samples I do have should showcase my abilities regardless. But apparently not.

Whatever, I sold an article to Babble the same day.grand street painter

Experience is Relative

My point is this: If we’re good at something, we’re good at it. End of story. Unless you’re a heart surgeon, experience is relative. Why should we have to work for years and years at something in order to validate ourselves and our “chosen career”? We ask children, “What do you want to be when you grow up?” and they answer: teacher, fireman, astronaut, ballerina. And from the very beginning we give kids the idea that they can only be really good at one thing. That everything else they’re passionate about has to be pushed to the side and gets put in that horrible category of “hobby”. Which as we know, never gets taken seriously.

Plus, these careers can’t work in tandem. If I were to be an editor, do that for five years, then suddenly turn around to be in sales, I’d have to start all the way at the bottom again. Except for the fact that things you learn from 5 years as an editor can be hugely helpful as a saleswoman. There’s this assumption that when we choose one thing, we’re then incompetent at others. Of course, there are exceptions: law enforcement, lawyers, doctors, where you obviously you need more training than a simple BA or editorial gig.

But still, I’ve always wanted to be a cop. Maybe someday I will. After I write a book, open a bakery, travel the world, be a photographer and generally find a way to nurture all my passions and get paid at the same time.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
  • http://twitter.com/brittany_belt/status/5621230666 Brittany Belt

    A rant on choosing only one career | marianlibrarian: http://is.gd/4RWod

  • http://mbreau.wordpress.com/ Melissa Breau

    Hi Marian,

    I’m afraid I disagree with you on some of your points, but I agree on your overall idea. However there are strategies out there for bypassing road blocks.

    When that editor told you you’d need to have written for a similar publication, you could have told her you’d write the piece without a kill-fee, or that you’d write it on spec. In other words, you’d write it and prove that it rocked. Despite her hesitation, being able to look at the finished article before agreeing to publish it might have swayed her, especially if she was as interested as you say.

    My only worry would be that if some of your samples didn’t impress her and that that was her “real” reason – it’s actually more important to have one or two really phenomenal samples than to have lots of samples (even if they’re only published online etc.) Haven’t not read your samples, but having read your writing, I doubt that’s the issue.

    It’s more likely she was worried that she would assign you the piece and then, because you don’t have the experience, you wouldn’t be able to follow through with your idea.

    It’s frustrating and I get it – but having read just about every book on freelancing in existence (if you’d like any recommendations let me know) there Are ways to look at it from the editors viewpoint and to offer them a way to accept you worry-free. It just depends if you’re willing to work that way.

    On your other point, it is not true at all that if you have experience in one aspect of publishing you have to start at the bottom when you switch to another interest in it. There are a TON of examples in the publishing world of people who have done this without starting from scratch.

    There are even examples of people who have switched from books to magazines etc. You’re right that if you have 2-3 years in editorial they probably won’t let you start off at an equal position in sales. But if you have 5-6 years or more, by that point chances are you’re at least dealing with sales on a regular enough basis…

    The best way to switch, of course, is to ascend the ladder … if you make it to the position of publisher from a sales side, it’s expected you’ll have an idea of how editorial works and vice-versa. The higher you are on the food chain the more likely you won’t have to start at the bottom.

    But again, you need to be willing to prove yourself. For example, if you’re working on editorial and you want to switch to sales approach whoever is in charge with a kick-ass sales idea to prove you can do it and that you have real ideas and can really improve their numbers because of your unique understanding.

  • http://mbreau.wordpress.com Melissa Breau

    Hi Marian,

    I’m afraid I disagree with you on some of your points, but I agree on your overall idea. However there are strategies out there for bypassing road blocks.

    When that editor told you you’d need to have written for a similar publication, you could have told her you’d write the piece without a kill-fee, or that you’d write it on spec. In other words, you’d write it and prove that it rocked. Despite her hesitation, being able to look at the finished article before agreeing to publish it might have swayed her, especially if she was as interested as you say.

    My only worry would be that if some of your samples didn’t impress her and that that was her “real” reason – it’s actually more important to have one or two really phenomenal samples than to have lots of samples (even if they’re only published online etc.) Haven’t not read your samples, but having read your writing, I doubt that’s the issue.

    It’s more likely she was worried that she would assign you the piece and then, because you don’t have the experience, you wouldn’t be able to follow through with your idea.

    It’s frustrating and I get it – but having read just about every book on freelancing in existence (if you’d like any recommendations let me know) there Are ways to look at it from the editors viewpoint and to offer them a way to accept you worry-free. It just depends if you’re willing to work that way.

    On your other point, it is not true at all that if you have experience in one aspect of publishing you have to start at the bottom when you switch to another interest in it. There are a TON of examples in the publishing world of people who have done this without starting from scratch.

    There are even examples of people who have switched from books to magazines etc. You’re right that if you have 2-3 years in editorial they probably won’t let you start off at an equal position in sales. But if you have 5-6 years or more, by that point chances are you’re at least dealing with sales on a regular enough basis…

    The best way to switch, of course, is to ascend the ladder … if you make it to the position of publisher from a sales side, it’s expected you’ll have an idea of how editorial works and vice-versa. The higher you are on the food chain the more likely you won’t have to start at the bottom.

    But again, you need to be willing to prove yourself. For example, if you’re working on editorial and you want to switch to sales approach whoever is in charge with a kick-ass sales idea to prove you can do it and that you have real ideas and can really improve their numbers because of your unique understanding.

  • Carin Siegfried

    Speaking as someone who DID switch from editorial to sales I’ll say that you might have to start at the bottom again, but the ascent is quick. You’re right – a lot of things I learned from being an editor were definitely helpful in sales. PS., before I was an editor, I was a buyer. So this wasn’t even my first left turn in this business! Onward and upward (and sideways.)

  • Carin Siegfried

    Speaking as someone who DID switch from editorial to sales I’ll say that you might have to start at the bottom again, but the ascent is quick. You’re right – a lot of things I learned from being an editor were definitely helpful in sales. PS., before I was an editor, I was a buyer. So this wasn’t even my first left turn in this business! Onward and upward (and sideways.)

  • Christine

    Love the lovely words about your mom, Marian. She thinks you’re swell too. Would you mind replacing that awful link to my book on Amazon with this one? http://www.nytimes.com/books/00/05/14/reviews/000514.14chaikit.html?_r=1

    The photo of my book, Deadly Departure, that one finds at Amazon is not of the actual cover, but some awful draft cover that I when it was first presented to me I found absolutely unacceptable. The book design that was then re created and the second production was magnificent. Sometimes it happens that way.
    Thanks honey.
    Love, Mom

  • Christine

    Love the lovely words about your mom, Marian. She thinks you’re swell too. Would you mind replacing that awful link to my book on Amazon with this one? http://www.nytimes.com/books/00/05/14/reviews/000514.14chaikit.html?_r=1

    The photo of my book, Deadly Departure, that one finds at Amazon is not of the actual cover, but some awful draft cover that I when it was first presented to me I found absolutely unacceptable. The book design that was then re created and the second production was magnificent. Sometimes it happens that way.
    Thanks honey.
    Love, Mom

  • Beth Oppenheim

    This is a really awesome post. Mostly because it echoes so many of the things that I have been feeling as I stay in the work force longer. My mother (contrastingly!) has been at the same place 21 years, and isn’t happy. It annoys me that she has done it to herself, and that many people do it to themselves. It is another generation’s mentality in a lot of ways.
    I love your post because you are right – unless you are a surgeon, or other careers in that path, you don’t need as much experience as you need someone to believe in you. It sounds like you (and your mom!) are awesome, and that your dreams will take you to a lot of great places. Best of luck along the way!!!

  • Beth Oppenheim

    This is a really awesome post. Mostly because it echoes so many of the things that I have been feeling as I stay in the work force longer. My mother (contrastingly!) has been at the same place 21 years, and isn’t happy. It annoys me that she has done it to herself, and that many people do it to themselves. It is another generation’s mentality in a lot of ways.
    I love your post because you are right – unless you are a surgeon, or other careers in that path, you don’t need as much experience as you need someone to believe in you. It sounds like you (and your mom!) are awesome, and that your dreams will take you to a lot of great places. Best of luck along the way!!!

  • Gia

    This is a great post and exactly how I feel at 23. You’ve really hit the nail on the head. Best of luck to you in all your future endeavors.

  • Gia

    This is a great post and exactly how I feel at 23. You’ve really hit the nail on the head. Best of luck to you in all your future endeavors.

  • Cathy

    “There’s this assumption that when we choose one thing, we’re then incompetent at others.”

    That can be true — if people don’t know you. They won’t be willing to put their own career and reputation on the line to see outside the cookie cutter lines of their ideal experience profile.

    When I’ve been most able in my career to make “weird” leaps (like going from being a secretary to an HR consultant) has been those times when I’ve connected with people who know my work ethic and so were willing to take a chance on me.

    That said, I lost my IT job last May and have decided to start my own biz in coaching/writing. That means creating a whole new network since my current network sees me as an IT person. I don’t want to pursue that path any more! :D

    So, I would tell anyone in college or in their 20′s, pursue as many of your interests as you can find the time to do so. Jump in, participate, build those relationships with those cops, bakers, photographers, so that when you’re my age (48) your network won’t be as narrow as mine was. It’s never too late — but it’s never too early either!

    Best of luck! (And, BTW, your mom sounds like she rocks!)

  • Cathy

    “There’s this assumption that when we choose one thing, we’re then incompetent at others.”

    That can be true — if people don’t know you. They won’t be willing to put their own career and reputation on the line to see outside the cookie cutter lines of their ideal experience profile.

    When I’ve been most able in my career to make “weird” leaps (like going from being a secretary to an HR consultant) has been those times when I’ve connected with people who know my work ethic and so were willing to take a chance on me.

    That said, I lost my IT job last May and have decided to start my own biz in coaching/writing. That means creating a whole new network since my current network sees me as an IT person. I don’t want to pursue that path any more! :D

    So, I would tell anyone in college or in their 20′s, pursue as many of your interests as you can find the time to do so. Jump in, participate, build those relationships with those cops, bakers, photographers, so that when you’re my age (48) your network won’t be as narrow as mine was. It’s never too late — but it’s never too early either!

    Best of luck! (And, BTW, your mom sounds like she rocks!)

  • admin

    Cathy, that is an excellent way at looking at it and really wonderful advice. Thank you for your insightful comment!

  • admin

    Cathy, that is an excellent way at looking at it and really wonderful advice. Thank you for your insightful comment!

  • http://jargonwriter.wordpress.com/ Melissa Breau

    Hi Marian, I came across this article today and immediately thought of you and this blog post. Check it out – the author is also on Brazen.

    http://www.more.com/2009/9171-confessions-of-a-serial-reinventor

  • http://jargonwriter.wordpress.com/ Melissa Breau

    Hi Marian, I came across this article today and immediately thought of you and this blog post. Check it out – the author is also on Brazen.

    http://www.more.com/2009/9171-confessions-of-a-serial-reinventor

  • Lori Dreyer

    Dear Marian,
    Great post…As a boomer though a late boomer…I think that we get labeled incorrectly …Most of my friends are many things..and many of us are trying to change careers too. It can be as hard to change careers as it is too break into a career. I know people who are trying to do something they do not have “that particular degree for” but have experiance actually doing the job….and find that the job goes to a 20 something out of college with “that degree” and no experience….Hmmm what’s up with that? the company will pay the no to little experiance alot less….Anyway..How did your Mom do it? Sounds like you have a great example?? WE all face barriers and I compeltely AGREE that mentality is so FRUSTRATING…..!!!! I think that the HR people who do the hiring are the people who need to get on board ..as they say…but they have to adhere to all sorts of federal and state regs in terms of discrimination etc. I think that is why people start their own companies. Good luck no matter what!! It is a journey!

  • Lori Dreyer

    Dear Marian,
    Great post…As a boomer though a late boomer…I think that we get labeled incorrectly …Most of my friends are many things..and many of us are trying to change careers too. It can be as hard to change careers as it is too break into a career. I know people who are trying to do something they do not have “that particular degree for” but have experiance actually doing the job….and find that the job goes to a 20 something out of college with “that degree” and no experience….Hmmm what’s up with that? the company will pay the no to little experiance alot less….Anyway..How did your Mom do it? Sounds like you have a great example?? WE all face barriers and I compeltely AGREE that mentality is so FRUSTRATING…..!!!! I think that the HR people who do the hiring are the people who need to get on board ..as they say…but they have to adhere to all sorts of federal and state regs in terms of discrimination etc. I think that is why people start their own companies. Good luck no matter what!! It is a journey!

  • Lisa

    Great article!

  • Lisa

    Great article!

  • Pingback: Being “Multi-Passionate” Does Not Mean Flaky | Marian Schembari

  • http://twitter.com/SweeneySays Nicole

    I agree with / love everything about this post. I just graduated in May so I'm going through the process of trying to “start at the bottom” somewhere, but it all starts to feel so overwhelming when I think about the fact that there are about a million different jobs I want to try to do. Good to see I'm not alone.

  • http://marianlibrarian.com Marian Schembari

    Oh my goodness, you are SO not alone! The more I write and the more I work for myself, the more I realize everyone feels this why. Honestly, it's a rare occasion where I meet a person (especially our age) who knows what the eff they want to do FOREVER. It's so frustrating that we're just expected to choose one! So don't feel bad or confused or alone, because my dear, we're all freaking multi-passionate and should flaunt it!

  • Pingback: My name is Marian and I am a Comment Whore — Marian Schembari

Previous post:

Next post: