Stop Ruining Pinterest for Everyone Who Loves It

by Marian Schembari on February 14, 2012

You know that obnoxious habit when you mention something new to a friend and they respond with “yeah, I heard about that ages ago” and you want to punch them in the mouth for being such a know-it-all? Well, everyone who’s been using Pinterest is starting to feel that way (re: we are the annoying know-it-all) now all the big marketing blogs are talking about it like they’ve discovered the Americas. (p.s. I’m not going to explain what Pinterest is. Go here if you want the details.)

Even though I work in marketing, I’m getting increasing frustrated at the industry’s new perspective of Pintrest…

  • Like this article that tells us “everything we need to know” but only actually tells us how to pimp your content to increase traffic.
  • Or this TechCrunch post that says Pinterest hasn’t yet reached its full potential because the audience is mostly women. (I wish I were kidding.)

And I’m not the only one. Pinterest lovers are annoyed because they’re all addicts. We’re all addicts. And I’m getting increasingly worried about sponsored pins, spam and generic crap being regurgitated into the webisphere.

That said, a) there’s nothing you nor I can do about it and b) there is opportunity because Pintrest is the best thing to happen to the internet since The Evolution of Dance. So I’m hoping with this post I can help the world use Pintrest for good instead of evil.

Here are some examples of companies on Pinterest, including what they do perfectly and who could use some work:

Modcloth

If Modcloth were a woman these boards would be everything she’d pin, making it as personal and personable as possible. It’s easily the best example of a brand on Pinterest.

Favorite Board: Behind the Stylebooks

Everyone loves a little behind-the-scenes, but Modcloth stands apart by showing what inspired their stylebooks, including typography, copy and vintage advertisements.

HGTV

A SparkNotes version of their website with awesome projects, design and food inspiration. While I’d usually consider this much HGTV content spammy, skimming through their projects in Pinterest-format is easier to digest.

Favorite Board: Mint Green: Color of the Month

This board gives you design ideas they might never have thought of under the umbrella of creative color.

The Travel Channel

What’s more inspirational than travel photos? The Travel Channel have organized their boards into different locations, with a few behind-the-scenes from their shows.

Favorite Board: Travel Finds

Travel Finds is a mash-up of inspirational travel quotes and nifty gadgets. It’s not too refined or particularly extensive, but that’s what I like about it.

Serious Eats

While the Serious Eats account is filled with gorgeous photos and dish ideas, they could do an even better job if they created other food-related boards like kitchen gadgets, restaurants, reviews and products they love.

Favorite Board: Booze-free drinks

Serious Eats organizes their boards  just like a cookbook! They have boards like Pasta and Noodles, Mexican, and Cocktails, as well as boards for events like Valentine’s Day and St. Patrick’s.

Kikki.k

Again, too product heavy, but stationery company Kikki.k does a decent job showing products in action. Their board featuring gorgeous workspaces makes me want to run right out and buy all their products. Nicely played, Kikki.k. Mission accomplished.

Favorite Board: Journal Prompts

Based off Kikki.k’s popular journals, this board features writing prompts. I love the concept, but the photos aren’t sexy enough to get much traction. If they really wanted to get some attention, they should use a kick ass graphic designer to mock up the prompts with some simple and unique typography.

So how do you use Pinterest without ruining it for those who adore it?

First of all, don’t jump on the bandwagon just because Mashable tells you to.

The one thing keeping me sane about the Pinterest explosion is that if you start spamming people or your content isn’t pretty enough, you’ll never getting your stuff repinned. Meaning right now (for now) its hard to game the system.

So since the site is mostly used for inspiration, if you have a blog about blogging you might be shit out luck. While I might create a board for my travels or the books I’ve read just to test it out, if you ever catch me trying to pimp my content you have my full permission to take me out back and shoot me.

What do you think, are your panties in a knot over brands finally discovering Pinterest? Have you ever even heard of it before? Could you care less?

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
  • http://www.domesticsluttery.com/ Siany

    I’ve only just jumped on the bandwagon, and I love it. It’s so much fun. But given that I run such an image-heavy blog it would be madness for me not to promote our stuff. The main reason I started was because people were doing it for us and I had no idea until recently:

    http://pinterest.com/source/domesticsluttery.com/

    I figured that if our community was already active on Pinterest, it made sense to join them. The don’t give a damn about Tumblr – we tried that.But spamming is something that I’m wary of especially since we’re such an active blog on our social media platforms. We’re chatty. I’m still getting used to what images work and what don’t. A great image in context of a blog post can actually look bland and dull on its own. And to make sure we don’t spam people, we’ve got a specific post for things from the blog:http://pinterest.com/domesticsluts/domestic-sluttery/

    We don’t deny we’re self-promoting (actually, we’re blatant about it), but we keep it all in one place and people can follow that board if they want to.What’s bugging me more is people who aren’t actively using Pinterest saying it’s not doing as well for brands as people think. People are being really quickly to slam it. All I can tell you is that after two weeks of active use (and not masses – we’ve only got about 200 pins over 8 or so boards), Pinterest is in our top ten traffic sources. I can’t argue with stats like that and they’re going to grow as we do. One of my favourite UK interiors blogs has almost half a million followers and a lot of that traffic is going to his blog – some of his pins are repinned thousands of times (jealous!) But it has to be approached like any new platform – full disclosure, sharing and talking to others.And basically not being a jerk.

    • http://marianlibrarian.com Marian Schembari

      Awesome! That’s so great to hear that Pintrest is doing so well for you guys – I’m unsurprised ;-) You have the perfect content for Pintrest and I think it will only continue to help your site in the long run.

      Just to clarify though, I’m not saying it’s a useless tool, I’m just worried about all these marketers jumping on the bandwagon because it’s the next cool thing. People need to understand exactly what kind of content it’s good for and what it’s not good for. That said, if it’s NOT good content I think the person pimping it won’t get very far.

      I haven’t heard one person say it’s not good for brands, but I’m also reading tech and marketing blogs that are salivating over the site. Basically, I’ll be interested to see how things progress. I just don’t want everything most of us have love and adored about Pintrest for months to go down the shitter.

      • http://www.domesticsluttery.com/ Siany

        Hah, maybe we’re all cynical in the UK. All we’re getting from the same stems is how it’s actually a waste of time and it’ll all fall to pieces. We’re deeply suspicious of anything that does well for some reason.

  • http://twitter.com/marianschembari/status/169424406525902848 Marian Schembari

    Stop Ruining Pintrest for Everyone Who Loves It http://t.co/vHtuoPdE

  • http://twitter.com/janetnorcal/status/169426243253583873 Janet Webb

    FYI @meganmulry — expert @MarianSchembari on:
    Stop Ruining Pintrest for Everyone Who Loves It http://t.co/1VWmH6cn

  • http://twitter.com/creativeally/status/169426876660584448 Sara Carbaugh

    Such a great article! RT @marianschembari: Stop Ruining Pintrest for Everyone Who Loves It http://t.co/ZLJgfTDt

  • http://twitter.com/lipdesign/status/169430134108069888 Lori I Paquette

    RT @creativeally: Such a great article! RT @marianschembari: Stop Ruining Pintrest for Everyone Who Loves It http://t.co/hdgPKbSe

  • Katie DeKoster

    This post just completely made my day! I was starting to just be over Pinterest, but I have a feeling that following the boards you mentioned will revive my habit! Thanks :)

    • http://marianlibrarian.com Marian Schembari

       Yay! Always nice to hear :)

  • http://twitter.com/howtorunaband/status/169826343830306816 Chris Seth Jackson

    Stop Ruining Pintrest for Everyone Who Loves It http://t.co/Ot9y8HRU

  • http://twitter.com/chicknamedd/status/169827207315853313 Donna Douglas

    RT @MarianSchembari: Stop Ruining Pintrest for Everyone Who Loves It http://t.co/9YfJKIZW

  • http://twitter.com/carmenboca/status/169903999078764544 carmen

    best thing I've read re: Pinterest & brands. it's a niche tool for god's sake http://t.co/XVqfcgJj by @MarianSchembari #IwillbeinNZsoon

  • http://twitter.com/conjirregverbs aidan larson

    you’re just cool. great post and thanks for the journal prompts board, hadn’t seen that one yet.
    aidan

    • http://marianlibrarian.com Marian Schembari

       YOU’RE just cool.

  • http://www.turtleduckpress.com/ Siri Paulson

    I’ve only just joined Pinterest and am still feeling my way around. I’m a fiction writer, and my Twitter presence is geared to that…but Pinterest is for me. So far I’ve been using it in the stereotypical ways — home decor, personal style, and wedding ideas — as well as for travel-related photos, geeky products, steampunk stuff, and photos that look like they could spark a story. I’m not getting many follows (but then I haven’t promoted my Pinterest presence elsewhere on the web at all), but I am getting plenty of repins.

    One of the articles you linked spoke about “curating content”, filtering the web to find the good stuff — it’s a way to create value for others. Blog link roundups, retweeting, and sharing on Facebook all do this. (For example, on Twitter, writer Elizabeth Craig doesn’t do personal tweets at all, but she’s always tweeting about excellent writing-related blog posts.) I think Pinterest will be a great way to do it as well. I’m hoping that people will find value in my boards and will then want to check out my website, rather than my pinning my own products. Of course, I’m not a retail store or a photographer or a magazine, so I don’t have many visual products to promote in the first place. But it’s the same philosophy I try to use on Twitter.

    Down the road, maybe I’ll get further into pinning stuff that’s more directly related to being a writer — inspiration boards for my works in progress, books I liked, stationery and pens and other writing-related swag, stuff calculated to appeal to my particular audience. Or maybe I won’t. Time will tell….

    • http://marianlibrarian.com Marian Schembari

      Amen to all of this! I wouldn’t stress too much about “creating content”. My fear surrounding Pintrest is that people will start using it to promote their stuff (whether that involves creating content or pimping their own crap) when I’ve just been using it for fun. Which is of course totally selfish of me, I know ;-)

  • http://twitter.com/conjirregverbs/status/170152538040049665 aidan larson

    RT @MarianSchembari: Stop Ruining Pintrest for Everyone Who Loves It http://t.co/afkXspQo

  • http://www.groundedtraveler.com Andrew

    I like Pinterest. Mostly as a visual way to organize the chaos of my normal internet research. I could care less if others repin my stuff. It is for my benefit that I pin things in the first place. I do have a board of my posts at GT, but only one, and it is labeled as such. The rest is my own fun. I’m also very selective of which boards I follow, at the same time I don’t really look at my “feed” so much.

  • http://twitter.com/alexisnasc/status/170636543495647232 Alexis Nascimento

    LOVE everything about this, except the blogger misspells Pinterest: Stop Ruining @Pinterest for Everyone Who Loves It http://t.co/9Oez7621

  • http://twitter.com/hleatherton/status/171354788666146816 Heather Eatherton

    How brands SHOULD use Pinterest with integrity. RT @MarianSchembari: Stop Ruining Pinterest for Everyone Who Loves It http://t.co/LPMI8aRC

  • http://twitter.com/geekyshopaholic/status/171365618723991554 Paula

    RT @MarianSchembari: Stop Ruining Pinterest for Everyone Who Loves It http://t.co/6kPENyxl

  • http://twitter.com/kim_lesch/status/171394343482048512 Kim Lesch

    RT @MarianSchembari: Stop Ruining Pinterest for Everyone Who Loves It http://t.co/4V2ggf6y

  • cala

    I wanted to take a look at the site but 1) had to wait several days to be sponsored or something so I could get my own account.  WTF is that about.
    2) once I got my own account, it seems the only way to actually log in is via facebook so I bailed and haven’t bothered with it since.  I refuse to get a facebook account to log into a site (I had a FB account for a while but dumped it not long after)

  • http://twitter.com/tenthmuse/status/172761795348533249 Joelle

    Totally. RT @MarianSchembari: Stop Ruining Pinterest for Everyone Who Loves It http://t.co/Md5umYLm

  • troublesometots

    Your post just summarized what I had suspected to be the truth about Pinterest but was worried I was wrong because of all of the “you need to get your crap on Pinterest yesterday!” blog posts out there. Thanks so much for confirming my suspicions :)

    I actually get traffic from Pinterest but I’m not sure how or why (I blog about babies and sleep, not about how to make your mudroom into a spa-like palace). But I think my own persona Pinterest boards are not going to be related to colicky babybies but stuff I’m interested in. Full stop :)

  • http://twitter.com/tinarayna_photo Tina

    I’ve been feeling exactly the same way lately!  suddenly I’ve been noticing companies posting tons of infographics on Pinterest that link back to their sites. That would be nice if the infographics were actually helpful, but most of the time, they’re just cluttered or mind-numbingly obvious.

  • http://twitter.com/hassanmirza/status/181534878930706435 Hassan Mirza

    Stop Ruining Pinterest for Everyone Who Loves It – by the always delightful @MarianSchembari http://t.co/x92hCVQz << nice case studies

  • Louboutinenspain

    Yo estaba sentado en casa la otra noche y decidimos ver Nip Tuck programa de televisión. Uno de ray ban los personajes principales, Christian Troy, llevaba gafas de sol, así que, como siempre, trató de ver lo que las gafas de sol que llevaba puesto. Resultó ser las gafas de sol Ray Ban. No estoy seguro de cuál es el modelo que llevaba ray ban gafas exactamente, pero eran Ray Ban Aviator estilos.
    Una vez más, es sorprendente cuántas personas aman a sus gafas de sol Ray Ban durante muchos años ray ban wayfarer ahora. Ha sido muy popular hace 20 años y sigue siendo popular hoy en día. Incluso los estilos más populares no ha cambiado desde entonces. Ray Ban era popular con gafas de sol originales Ray Ban Wayfarer y gafas de sol de aviador en ese entonces y estos 2 estilos siguen siendo una ray ban aviator locura popular para una generación de personas.
    Para aquellos de ustedes que todavía no le debo un par de gafas de sol Ray Ban te recomiendo que echa un vistazo a su colección en nuestro sitio web!

  • http://twitter.com/brittianykirk/status/194264359340486656 Brittiany Kirk

    HAHA LOVE this take on What @Pinterest is becoming @jillianbird http://t.co/uJXzof3F

Previous post:

Next post: